skip menus and go right to content



LifeWatch Employee Assistance Program




Topic Home  Related:  
Book Review - Acquiring Genomes
Acquiring Genomes
by Lynn Margulis and Dorion Sagan
Basic Books, 2002
Review by Martin Hunt
Jan 24th 2003

Acquiring Genomes by Lynn Margulis and Dorion Sagan is a well-argued, lucid book about evolutionary theory that is accessible to the non-specialist reader. Margulis and Sagan offer a radical extension of evolutionary theory.  They propose a mechanism for evolutionary change that is largely outside the mainstream of evolutionary theory that emphasizes mutation by random genetic mutation.  The extension offered is the "symbiogenesis" of new species. Symbiogenesis is the process of creating new species by the merging of previously separate genomes that have come to have a symbiotic relationship to each other.

The idea of symbiosis is central to Margulis and Sagan's thesis. This is a familiar idea -- different species live together so closely that they are mutually dependant on each other.  For instance, we all have in our guts a particular kind of bacteria that is essential for the digestion of food.  The bacteria are essential to us because we would die of starvation without them.  We are essential for those bacteria as well.  The bacteria and we live in a state of mutual dependence.  Symbiosis can occur at a high level. For instance there are birds that make their living by plucking parasites from the backs of rhinoceroses. The birds and the rhinos are symbionts. Margulis and Sagan make this idea of symbiosis a little more rigorous than usual.  Since each kind of creature has a unique genome (that is, a unique genetic structure), they define symbiosis as the "living together of different genomes".

Under conditions of stress, the previously coexisting genomes actually merge to become one genome. A new unified individual is created where formerly there were two. This passage from page 90 describes the process.

"Under stress, different kinds of individuals, of very different origins and abilities, often associate. With continued and predictable stress, often cyclical and seasonal, these acquaintances become intimate and extend beyond a single encounter. To become significant to the evolutionary process, the former strangers must interact frequently enough to form stable, unique relationships and form a permanent or deeply seasonal affair.  Put succinctly, in the cases important in evolution, associations lead to partnerships that lead to symbioses that leads to new kinds of individuals formed by symbiogenesis."

Symbiogenensis is a difficult idea to accept from the perspective that is natural for humans.  For us, significant creatures are other creatures our ancestors and we have encountered in our daily lives. We relate to birds and mammals and fish and reptiles and plants easily because all of these kinds of life are on a scale that is easy for us to perceive.  And it is hard to imagine the rhinos and their symbiont birds merging to become a new kind of creature.

The matter is easier to understand if we consider cows. Cows have a special stomach, containing a special bacterium.  This second stomach is one of the defining characteristics that distinguishes cows from (say) antelopes.  That second stomach is caused by the genome of the cow to provide an environment for the genome of the bacteria that live in that stomach. It isn't so much of a jump from here to the idea that the cow is in fact a mixture of two genomes.

Most life on the planet Earth is bacterial. Bacteria exist at the top of the atmosphere and deep in the earth's crust. Whereas there are many metabolic systems among bacteria, all animals and plants share only one metabolic process.  Central to the thesis of Acquiring Genomes is the realization that species do not exist among bacteria. Bacterial genomes are so fluid and changeable that the concept of species is meaningless when applied to them.

One of the central points of Acquiring Genomes is that symbiotic associations of bacteria are the basis of all multicellular forms of life.  Traditionalists will object and point out that bacteria are fundamentally different from the cells of which multicellular life is constructed.  The cells of animals and plants have a well-defined nucleus that exists within its own membrane (sort of a cell within a cell). Such cells are called "eukaryotic cells".  In contrast, bacteria do not have a nucleus within a membrane -- they are "prokaryotic cells".  Margulis pointed out many years ago that eukaryotic cells are actually symbiotic combinations of prokaryotic cells. DNA, located in the nucleus of eukaryotic cells, came from one kind of bacterium and the mitochondria and the cellular machinery outside the nucleus came from another.  Therefore, the very existence of multicellular life is a result of a symbiotic merging among bacterial predecessors and therefore the process of symbiogenesis is fundamental to the very existence of species.  To the question: "How did species acquire their genomes?" Margulis and Sagan answer, "By the merging of separately evolved bacterial genomes."

Acquiring Genomes introduces the reader to a very interesting idea of surprising scope.  As a bonus, the book is well written and a pleasure to read and is chock full of interesting examples.  For example -- have you heard about the photosynthetic slug? It incorporates algae into its tissues, is green, and never eats - but basks in the sun in the shallow waters of the seashore. In the mind of this reviewer Acquiring Genomes provides an excellent account of where genomes come from; that is, from bacteria.  The thesis though, that symbiogenesis is the main process driving evolutionary change, is not so well established -- just what causes a change from an ancestor to a descendant "species" is still an open question.


© 2003 Martin Hunt


Martin Hunt is an artist living and working in Vancouver, Canada. His work is inspired by math and science. Lately he's been indulging an interest in evolutionary theory and its relation to consciousness.